While reading Don't Make Me Think, however, I began to notice that GOOP probably doesn't fall in line with Krug's recommendations. I still find GOOP very attractive, though, and I think it's navigable and it does hold my attention.
Here's a screenshot of the main page for GOOP:

It doesn't explain itself (except for the "by Gwyneth Paltrow" part...maybe the addition of a familiar name makes the website instantly "familiar?"). The navigation tools aren't very illuminating (you don't know what you're clicking until you click). Generally speaking, the purpose of the website is entirely unclear.
Maybe it is trying to reach a specific audience...an audience that I clearly am a part of, because, as I said, I really like this website, and I was initially attracted to it because of its homepage.
I'm not saying I necessarily disagree with Krug, but perhaps his ideas of web design are confined to a specific kind of website for a particular audience.
Again, I'm not exactly certain of the target audience for GOOP, besides people like me who get excited by pretty colors and a simplistic design, but it seems as though Krug has very specific ideas about websites as they relate to businesses and marketing. Perhaps other kinds of websites should be granted more lee-way, and room for creativity, to reach their specific audience.